We live in challenging times. How do we reinvent ourselves when something unexpectedly life changing happens? What resources do we access, what coping skills do we summon? So many people I know have navigated huge changes in their lives. One friend lost her husband to a heart attack; another lost her long-term partner to Alzheimer's. One left a cheating boyfriend only to live through Hurricane Katrina. One had a suicidal partner. Six managed cancer diagnoses. Is there an epidemic of challenges these days or is this just what life parcels out?
Whatever it was, I was curious: What combination of luck and skill allows women to manage life’s challenges? I decided to interview five resilient women and ask about their coping strategies.
Felice Batlan and I met in the 1980s, when we belonged to the same book group in Manhattan. Over the years, we saw each other sporadically. I knew she had moved to New Orleans to teach law at Tulane and subsequently moved to Chicago, where she also taught law. When we spoke, she was packing up her place in New Orleans, where she had returned to teach for the semester.
“My story begins on 9/11,” Batlan said. A graduate of Harvard law school with a PhD in history from NYU, Batlan had been recruited for a job at Cantor Fitzgerald, where she had many friends, some of whom died when the towers fell. Meanwhile, her partner of 10 years, who was bipolar and untreated, had been cheating on her and doing risky things.
"I had to get out of New York,” Batlan said. A job offer came from Tulane law school and she moved to New Orleans. "It was like a fairytale,” Batlan said. “But maybe I was a little naive in not seeing all of its problems.” Still, the first year was a dream come true: ”I loved my teaching colleagues, my students, loved the parades, Mardi Gras and Halloween.”
Then, Hurricane Katrina struck. “It was this unbelievable shock,” Batlan said. “I didn't know enough to have an evacuation plan.” She embarked on a journey of what felt like homelessness. “My research in those days was on paper. I felt like I had lost everything. I didn’t have anywhere to go, it was complete disaster.”
She moved back to New York, where she stayed with friends. “They made their homes open to me. I showed up with nothing, I literally had a pair of underwear.” Still, she found the normalcy and kindness she encountered in New York disorienting: “People would be excited about the U.S. Open and I’d be on the floor bawling.”
Batlan returned to New Orleans six weeks after Katrina and went to her office, where the windows had blown out: “Mostly everything in my office was destroyed.” But her cell phone was working so she and a friend decided to set up a legal booth at the FEMA center. "The work gave me a sense of purpose and a professional identity and that was crucial.” But when her lease ended in April, her landlord did not renew it and she had to sleep on a friend's couch for the rest of the semester while she completed her teaching commitments. “There was no available housing and that was the last straw,” Batlan says.
She accepted a tenure track job at IIT-Chicago Kent School of Law. “The city had electricity and hot water and stoplights and restaurants. I needed to be in a space that was not dealing with massive trauma.” Almost 20 years after leaving New Orleans, she returned last fall to teach again at Tulane. “I had a lack of closure,” Batlan says. “The last months (post Katrina) were so awful. I wanted to come back and renew friendships and get acquainted with the city again. New Orleans has always been a city of reinvention. I’m making my Mardi Gras costume,” she says happily.
My husband’s aunt Elaine Strum, 79, is one of the most resilient women I know. When she was in her early 30s, her husband, also in his early 30s, was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer and died. They had been married for 11 years and had two young sons. Because she was so young, Strum didn’t know other widows. “I tried to find people in similar situations to me," she says, including a woman whose husband had been murdered.
Both Strum's parents and her in-laws lived in Philadelphia but her in-laws were preparing to buy an apartment in Del Ray and live there six months a year.
“Eventually my in-laws moved to Florida permanently and helped me raise my kids,” Strum says. She studied for a masters degree in marriage and family counseling, and eventually went to work as an actuary. Over time, she met Bill, a writer, who became her long-term partner; he moved into her house when her sons were teenagers.